Political Enthusiast Legalize Prostitution Every country in the world has prostitution, the longest running profession. The only difference within prostitution is the legal status surrounding it. For example, The United States where prostitution is illegal, with the sole exception of Nevada, has had a long running taboo of prostitution.
Download this Thesis in word format. And as far back asthe San Francisco Committee on Crime considered the legalization of prostitution a "feasible" approach to the issues involved. In addition, inthe California Senate Committee on the Judiciary gave their support for a legalized sex trade Rio, So why, more than thirty years later, has no progress been made in this arena?
Particularly from a criminal justice perspective, what is the current rationale for criminalizing this activity? Causes and Effects Traditional arguments against the legalization of prostitution relate to America's Puritan roots and issues of morality.
No matter that prostitution and pornography are billion dollar industries tied to human nature and impossible to eradicate; many citizens and legislators simply cannot stomach the thought of "allowing" a sex trade. In a thorough analysis of the issue inTabbash lists many arguments against criminalizing prostitution for moral reasons: Tabbash also argues that a genuine concern for women would offer them "equal rights and opportunity," as well as an end to "turning some of them into criminals merely because they have chosen to exchange sex for money.
But evidence shows that legalizing prostitution works to reduce, rather than exascerbate, these problems. Attempting to deny that the sale of sex is a prominent, pervasive, and permanent aspect of human society by Legalizing prostitution thesis it does nothing to inhibit or prevent it Tabbash, Other traditional arguments against legalizing the sale of sex are related to the background of women who choose this means of existence.
In many cases, these women come from childhoods of abuse, neglect, drug use, and economic struggles. The argument is that these women are not truly choosing to sell their bodies, but are forced to by circumstance. While this may be true in many cases, criminalizing prostitution without spending an equal amount of time Legalizing prostitution thesis money on placing these women in more "respectable" jobs and offering them rehabilitation services and health protection does nothing to improve their lives Tabbash, Moreover, the fact that prostitution is a criminal activity sold on the "black market" contributes to its profitability for women.
The argument that women who work as prostitutes suffer from low self-esteem and mental illnesses such as Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder PTSD as a result of their way of life are also weak. Experts argue that low self-esteem is most often rooted in childhood experiences, and the criminal stigma attached to prostitution in American society is itself the cause of this self-degradation.
More importantly, the stresses involved in prostitution that result in mood and other mental disorders among sex workers are directly the result of its criminalization. The regulation of this industry would bring these women indoors, protect them from venereal disease and unwanted pregnancy, shield them from abusive pimps and serial killers, and provide them with a sense of belonging absent in the world of prostitution today Tabbash, Nations such as Canada, with more progressive views of the legalization of prostitution, note that leaving the sex trade on the streets results in "residential and commercial areas often experiencing traffic congestion, noise, litter, harassment of residents, declining property values, and loss of legitimate businesses" John Howard Society Contributors,preface.
Again, regulation and legalization would reduce or eliminate these issues, rather than aggravate them. The potential effect on families is another sensitive issue surrounding prostitution. As the Alberta, Canada official discourse on prostitution of stated: However, these family-centered problems are just as likely to result from legal activities such as the patronization of strip clubs, the purchase of pornography, or the abuse of alcohol.
In fact, it's arguable that the thousands of women "acting" in pornographic films are participating in a legalized form of prostitution.
This precedent was set in the state of California in when Harold Freeman, a pornography director, was freed by the California Supreme Court on charges of pimping for hiring adult actors to perform sex acts.
Freeman's arrest was part of an attempt by California law enforcement to put an end to the industry; however, their plan backfired when the Supreme Court of California ruled in favor of Freeman, and "the making of hardcore pornography was effectively legalized" Zirkle,p. Approaches and Solutions In response to the great debate over prostitution and its effects on society, three basic approaches have emerged and been adopted by governments: In addition, there are many proactive practices that communites have successfully implemented to improve issues surrounding the sale of sex, provided they have government cooperation.
These can include "legalizing brothels, implementing prostitution offender programs, mailing out "Dear John" letters, and creating zones of tolerance" John Howard Society Contributors,preface.
In Canada, social programs have also been developed to offer aid and support to prostitutes in need of medical care, counseling or alternative job options John Howard Society Contributors, Among law enforcement officials themselves, who have experience the effects of prostitution firsthand, the debate is just as fierce and difficult to nail down.
One common argument for legalization revolves around safety issues for female sex workers. Dozens of studies also offer statistics in support of a more realistic approach to the problems surrounding prostitution. Through legalization, the price may not drop in America, but the majority of profits could go toward the economy and government programs that work to improve society as a whole, rather than benefitting individual pimps and prostitutes.
This in itself could greatly reduce the attractiveness of prostitution as a means of financial gain. Sexually-transmitted Disease, Violence, and Power Struggles Since many prostitutes suffer from poverty as a result of spending their earnings on illegal drugsa limit on their profits, as well as laws against drug use among prostitutes, could greatly reduce this problem as well.
Cundiff's research also reinforces other studies claiming that the legalization of prostitution reduces the incidence of rape. In fact, Cundiff states that with a population of roughly million, the United States could expect a "decrease of approximately 25, rapes per year" as a result of decriminalizing prostitution Cundiff,p.
HIV and other sexually-transmitted diseases are another major concern among prostitutes and "johns. I look at this as a health problem. Law enforcement officers from Nevada counties where brothels have been legal since are supportive of the policy.Prostitution Thesis. For Later. save. Related.
Embed. Share. Print. Search. Related titles. Prostitution f fin. Thesis Chapter 1 to 3. Prostitution. Prostitution and Ethics. Legalizing prostitution gets rid of its criminal elements. Prostitution is a natural form of human sexuality FACT: The sex of prostitution is not sex for.
Legalized Prostitution – Essay Sample Opposition Argument No matter how potent the arguments are for the benefits in legalizing prostitution, they cannot compensate for one fact: that, from a deontological standpoint, both participants are behaving in what is, at best, a morally questionable way.
Introduction. Given the sacred nature that rests behind sexual activity, prostitution should not be legalized no matter what. Presently, many countries are keenly looking into legalizing prostitution, and thus decriminalizing the illicit sex industry, as established by Raymond ().
Prostitution essays / Presuasive Essay On Legalizing Prostitution Prostitution The legalization of prostitution would be beneficial to America.
Since prostitution is a victimless crime we should stop putting so much time, effort, and money into prostitution enforcement and put it towards something more useful.
Excerpt from Thesis: As far back as , the United Nations recognized the logic and benefits of decriminalizing prostitution, and organizations supporting this decriminalization include the "American Civil Liberties Union, the National Organization of Women, and various prostitute 'unions', the most famous of which is COYOTE (Call Off Your Old Tired Ethics)" (Rio, , p. ). Legalizing Prostitution Essay Example Words | 10 Pages. Thesis: Legalizing prostitution could help clean up the streets, lower taxes, lower the rate of rape and the rate of organized crime. From one of the world’s oldest . Prostitution essays / Presuasive Essay On Legalizing Prostitution Prostitution The legalization of prostitution would be beneficial to America. Since prostitution is a victimless crime we should stop putting so much time, effort, and money into prostitution enforcement and put it towards something more useful.
Thesis Legalizing Prostitution in California This and 90,+ more term papers written by professionals and your peers. Despite such opposition to legalizing prostitution, many argue that legalizing it would result in decreased morality issues, increase the economic activity in the United States, and help decrease the number of sexually transmitted diseases among both prostitutes and those who patronize them, The most common argument against the legalization .